Brazil-South Africa Recap

June 26th, 2009 | By: Duvel | 8 Comments »

Brazil 1 – 0 South Africa

We knew this was going to be a tough match. Playing the host nation is always challenging. However, Brazil’s performance cannot be justified on this fact. From the very beginning of the match the team looked lethargic. This match reminded me of the Brazil-Bolivia qualifier in Rio. Like the Bolivians, South Africa stacked the box completely and Brazil was unable to show any creativity to counter this.

I know some folks cannot understand sometimes why Brazilians give Dunga a hard time. This match illustrated why this is the case. You could see it in Dunga’s face that he knew the team was playing poorly and that he was extremely concerned. However, he waited until the 81st minute to do ANYTHING about that. There should have been changes made at the half. How many managers wait that long to make a change? The team always finds a way to take a step back after taking a step forward under him.

Robinho did not have a good match. My grandfather made the point last night that Robinho’s “trickery” on the counter is actually holding up the attack by a few seconds, allowing South Africa to get back defensively. That little hesitation and step over he does is not fooling anyone. Pato or Julio Baptista should have come on for him. Baptista had his best matches for Roma this season when playing on the left. This was a game that called for his instant presence on the pitch.

I thought Ramires should have been pulled during the second half. He is a young, inexperienced player, so its understandable that he isn’t a revelation every time on the pitch. Elano should have come on, but he was nowhere to be seen.

The reality is that Brazil should have lost this match. If its not for Julio Cesar, who is by far my man of the match, Brazil loses this match 2 or 3-1. Dunga better expect the U.S. to play a similar match to South Africa this weekend in terms of tactics.

Player Ratings:

Julio Cesar, 8.5, How many times is he the difference between wins and losses?

Maicon, 6, Was surprisingly quiet and did not have nearly the type of match we’ve seen from him in this tournament.

Luisao, 5.5, He is so clumsy its not even funny. I said Miranda should have started this match and Luisao’s performance backed that up.

Lucio, 7.5, I thought Lucio had a strong match. He was active on both ends of the pitch.

Andre Santos, 7, I thought he had a good match defensively. He had a couple of bad giveaways on the attach, but did better than people are giving him credit for.

Gilberto Silva, 6.5, Gave the ball up a few times. Was kind of invisible on the pitch.

Felipe Melo, 6, I thought he had a worse game than people are giving him credit for. He too had a few poor giveaways.

Ramires, 6, Basically the same as Felipe Melo. Drew the foul that let to the Dani Alves free kick.

Robinho, 5.5, Like I’ve been saying its only bad or great games from him, this was bad. We can’t afford people taking nights off in 2010.

Kaka, 6, He was active, but rather ineffective yesterday.

Luis Fabiano, 7, He created a couple of chances. He worked his tail off and its not his fault his midfield wasn’t creating anything.

Subs:

Dani Alves, 8, What a goal huh?

Kleberson, N/A



Related Posts



Subscribe
 

rss icon Brazil World Cup RSS Feed

Print
Print this article
Share
del.icio.us:Brazil-South Africa Recap digg:Brazil-South Africa Recap newsvine:Brazil-South Africa Recap reddit:Brazil-South Africa Recap fark:Brazil-South Africa Recap Y!:Brazil-South Africa Recap stumbleupon:Brazil-South Africa Recap

Comments
Username By Antihate | June 26th, 2009 at 5:54 pm
top comment
cornercorner

Yea pretty bad. Your break down is pretty perfect. There is no distribution form the central midfield positions. Melo played miserable passes, but was ok defensively. Ramires has been great up until this game, but played TAY-REE-BLE last night! He shoudl’ve came out in the 55 minute. Lucio as you said was great. I think he’s an amazing Center back now. He was good before but now he looks amazing. And you weren’t lying about Luisao. He is the biggest liability on the field. All his tackles were fouls on Parker. That was scary watching him defend. I thought he was going to give up a PK sooner or later, but he just gave up some dangerous free kicks. And yea, now I see why people don’t really have the utmost confidence in Dunga. He could’ve made those subs way earlier in the match and things could’ve changed for the better earlier. Danny Alves looked great in the 9+ minutes he played. And Anderson at Left back wasn’t too bad, but he was struggling with Gaka.

Not to discount South Africa, because they brought it.

Sorry for the book.

I hope Dunga and Brazil learn from this mistake and go on to beat the pants off of the US again.

cornercorner
Username By josi | June 26th, 2009 at 10:00 pm
top comment
cornercorner

Duvel you dont know where you are talking about. How do you mean Gilberto Silva was invisible, he was all over the field breaking up attacks and spraying passes forward to robinho and kaka. I think the defenders including Luisao played extremely well. Robinho had a poor game, his problem is that he needs to learn how to shoot from distance like what rivaldo used to do. Dunga and the shooting staff needs to work on that.Yes I agree Ramirez is not the finish product but I re watched the matched and I saw how he put pressure on the defenders and also he is very quick.

cornercorner
Username By Duvel | June 26th, 2009 at 11:21 pm
top comment
cornercorner

Antihate, thanks for the comments. I agreed with what you had to say. Hopefully we will see Miranda get the nod over Luisao.

Josi, a little harsh on the comments, but its always good to get another opinion. I saw Gilberto Silva give up possession on multiple occasions. His lack of pace is one of Brazil’s problems, especially in games like this where the opposing team is stacking the box. It wasn’t just me that gave Gilberto Silva and Luisao those ratings. Goal.com gave comparable ones to those two players: http://www.goal.com/en/news/1863/world-cup-2010confederations-cup/2009/06/25/1346723/confederations-cup-player-ratings-brazil-1-0-south-africa

But then again they only gave Julio Cesar a 7 for his outstanding performance…

Posted from United States United States

cornercorner
Username By Samuel. | June 26th, 2009 at 11:48 pm
top comment
cornercorner

Julio Cesar is the worlds greatest Goalkeeper. he’s awesome! anyhow i also think that Ramirez and Robinho were pathetic last night. Kaka tried but just couldnt get into the game as he wished to. Joel Santana’s organization of his South African players was very organized & disciplined. Gilberto Silva in my opinion was average, he did nothing fancy in the attack nor did he do something significant defensively but he kept things ticking away nicely. but Melo was simply guilty of too much turnovers!

Posted from United States United States

cornercorner
Username By shingai | June 27th, 2009 at 10:41 am
top comment
cornercorner

Interesting…but the way Dunga has built his squad, there really isn’t a place for a player like Pato – almost like Carlo Ancelotti’s X-mas tree, with a big striker (a la Ronaldo) up front. Pato is best as a second striker, so I’m thinking his best chance to crack into the squad is taking Robinho’s spot. But Dunga seems to have a hardon for Robinho, whose useless and predictable moves annoy me.

Posted from United States United States

cornercorner
Username By Duvel | June 27th, 2009 at 12:09 pm
top comment
cornercorner

I agree that Pato would need to take Robinho’s place. Luis Fabiano is an asset to the team and gives good performances generally everytime out. Robinho’s inconsistency is troubling. I think Pato deserves the start in our next friendly, depending on that we could better make a set of judgments.

Posted from United States United States

cornercorner
Username By Gautam | June 28th, 2009 at 12:56 am
top comment
cornercorner

I completely agree with Duvel. Dunga waited for 81 st minute and Brazil
could have been 2-0 down if not for Julio Caesar. Gilberto Silva as i said
shud retire gracefuly he is old and slow now and simply out of his league.
Elano and Baptista were crying needs which our boxing coach cud not figure out. And I completely agree with the observation that Robinho is slowing down the attack and he is also losing posession. Kaka was alright
we cannot expect him to carry the team on his own every time. Melo, less said about him the better it is. Santos is inexperienced but he worked hard still his defence needs improvement. Jozi seems to have watched a different match than the rest of us. What a lethargic performence in semis of a top tournament by the 5 times world champions. The only redeeming feature was the beauty free kick produced by Alves. Forget about 2010 WC with this level of performence and craetivity.

Posted from India India

cornercorner
Username By Duvel | June 28th, 2009 at 8:27 am
top comment
cornercorner

Thanks for the comment Gautam. It will interesting to see how the team performs today after playing so poorly. Dunga has shown a recent willingness to make changes after such showings, and I think you’ll see him shake some things up for the better.

Posted from United States United States

cornercorner


Comments are closed


 
Go to WCB Homepage




Send Your Tips!

Found a great story, photo or video that's perfect for World Cup Blog?
Email tips[at]worldcupblog[dot]org

Brazil Club Football News

More South America Blogs

Monthly Archives

closer
World Cup Blog